I personally know of many Wiccans who are vital and active members of the Fraternity. As long as you can state a belief in a Supreme Being (in your case, the Goddess), no one can ask you as to the nature of that belief. However, if you have any personal objections to the ceremonial use of the Bible in the lodge, you may find participation in the Lodge uncomfortable. This has never been a problem for the Wiccan Masons I know, but it has been an issue for others who have chosen not to petition for membership.
You might find the following webpage of interest: Masonic Info; Wicca & Freemasonry
I can say the same for several Taoists I know—some are active Masons, who are happy in their Masonic labors, but I know of at least two men who could not state a belief in a Supreme Being (i.e., who could not, by their own beliefs, attribute a particular “consciousness” or “intelligence” to the Tao), and therefore chose not to join.
However, I should add that I also know of one person that I personally sponsored who made the “mistake” of stating his belief in the Goddess as his Supreme Being, and was (wrongfully, by the tenets of Freemasonry) not elected to join the lodge (who were apparently unaware that they had elected & initiated another Wiccan two years earlier, as that Brother did not offer details of the Supreme Being in which he believed). I’m very happy to say that the “oldtimers” - Masons who are veterans of WWII, and who are very conservative in regards to what we can or cannot ask, as Masons, from a Candidate - who were present at that ballot were very upset & angry with the course of the debate, and made sure that the man had another opportunity to petition a different lodge some time later. (The two Masons who were loudest in their objections were, oddly enough, Catholics in their 50s, who had redefined - in their own minds - the requirements for Masonic membership as a specific belief in the Bible, which is NOT what is asked of a Candidate for Masonry.) Having left New York, I do not know what happened in the end, as I’ve lost touch with the person who made that application.